QOTD -- Changing The SCOTUS Strike Zone

 

"The trouble that the media is having in settling on a coherent frame for this specific decision is both entirely the problem and entirely beside the point. The real story of the two decisions in U.S. v. Texas and Whole Woman’s Health v. Jackson is that Chief Justice John Roberts has now lost control of his court. As was the case in the very first shadow docket order that allowed S.B. 8 to go into effect, despite abundant evidence that it was materially harming pregnant people and clearly violated Roe v. Wade, the vote today was 5-4, again with the court behaving as though there is nothing unusual about the Texas scheme. The chief justice had over three months to change a single mind on the conservative flank of the court. He failed to do so. Writing for those five justices, Neil Gorsuch lays out myriad stumbling blocks and problems with the abortion providers’ theory before granting them very limited relief against four state licensing officials who have some authority to enforce S.B. 8.  [snip]

"Roberts is credited with soothing us that Supreme Court justices are never doing anything more than calling balls and strikes. But under his watch, a conservative supermajority has changed the strike zone, corked the bats, and set the whole infield on fire—all while telling us that the game remains the same. They managed all that with the help of one Chief Justice John Roberts. What this tiny, narrow, wholly radical ruling reveals is that Roberts is now alone in his concern that the fans might soon figure all this out. His problem? He’s not the one calling the game anymore." -- Dahlia Lithwick, writing in Slate that "John Roberts Has Lost Control." The decisions by the Gang of Five radical right justices (that Roberts is belatedly concerned about) effectively amount to nullification of Court rulings by Republican state legislatures, with the Court's blessing.  Of course, a Democratic legislature pulling an end run around, say, a gun rights ruling would doubtless be greeted with less enthusiasm by the Gang of Five.  They'd just change the strike zone to match their partisan views -- that's the "stench" that Justice Sotomayor said was on the Court now.