Showing posts with label Fox "News" settles Dominion lawsuit for $787.5 million. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Fox "News" settles Dominion lawsuit for $787.5 million. Show all posts

Monday, April 24, 2023

The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly

 

The good:

...The decision to maintain the status quo on mifepristone by the same court that struck down Roe v Wade may be a quiet nod to the waning legitimacy of the court, and a concern about further backlash.

But what if the politics of judicial reform are already shifting under the justices’ feet?

The high-profile state Supreme Court race in Wisconsin — and the potential fallout — suggests that may be the case. During the midterms, that quintessential purple state delivered slim victories to a Democratic governor and a Republican senator. Less than five months later, though, a left-leaning candidate, Judge Janet Protasiewicz, ran up a double-digit advantage over her right-of-center opponent. [snip]

But Wisconsin’s judicial election earlier this month suggests that the White House’s assessment of how judicial politics plays among Democratic voters no longer holds water. That election may signal a broader shift in the tectonics of voter mobilization in respect to courts and judges more generally.

The most obvious reason for thinking something has changed is that it was Democrats, and not Republicans, who were galvanized by the judicial election. These voters, moreover, were moved by the issue of judicial power but were not motivated as much by the goal of electing Democrats. In a state Senate race held that same day, the Republican candidate eked out a win. That too was a highly consequential election, giving Republicans a Senate supermajority and the votes to oust officials through impeachment.  [snip]

If the political script on judicial power gets flipped in Wisconsin — if GOP legislators act to rein in a liberal-leaning court — what could this bode for a broader change nationally? Or what happens if conservative federal judges or Supreme Court justices advance a far-right agenda reviled by progressives and even many centrists?

Surely, the next time Democrats have full control of Washington, the push to overhaul the judiciary will be a top priority, if they have the votes.

That the mifepristone case was ever heard, much less advanced to the Supreme Court, is a testament to the extent to which the judicial branch, at least in certain circuits, has been filled with radical right- wing Republicans (i.e., Christofascists).  The Supreme Court's Republican supermajority is, if nothing else, highly partisan and political.  They see the ground shifting against their party on the abortion issue and may be acting to stem the damage.  Elections matter.

The bad:

Fox Corp.’s $787.5 million settlement with Dominion Voting Systems over defamation charges is eye-popping, but the ultimate cost to the media company is likely to be much lower. [snip]

How much the lawsuit will actually end up costing Fox is unclear because there are ways it can defray some of the expense, primarily through insurance and the use of tax deductions.

Fox can deduct the Dominion settlement from its income taxes as an expense necessary for the cost of doing business. Fox Chief Communications Officer Brian Nick has confirmed the deductibility of the settlement.

Big companies often deduct large settlements to help offset some of the cost, but since settlement amounts are usually confidential, it’s difficult to pin down exactly how much they benefit. Payments that are seen as restitution or compensation can be deducted, while payments made to the government or at the direction of a government are usually not deductible.

Robert Willens, a tax professor at the Columbia University School of Business, estimates that after the tax write-off, Fox will incur about three-fourths of the settlement amount, about $590 million...

The settlement wasn't going to change the Fox "News" business model, but seeing them get away with this is infuriating.  All the more reason the Smartmatic lawsuit needs to go through the trial process to bring as much pain to these bastards as possible.

The ugly:

Nearly every 2024 GOP presidential contender or likely candidate that spoke at a major evangelical gathering in Iowa over the weekend vowed to fight against “woke” transgender policies.

The fact that not a single person on stage mentioned same-sex marriage, the banning of which was once a top priority for social conservatives, put a punctuation mark on the new rallying cry on the right.

The GOP’s shift on social issues is the result of quickly changing public attitudes ― including within their own party ― toward the acceptance of gay marriage, as well as polls that show some Americans’ unease with the pace of change on trans issues.  [snip]

Former Vice President Mike Pence received a warm reception from the crowd after he framed the fight over trans issues as one based on religious freedom. He also praised Iowa for passing legislation that banned gender-affirming medical care for minors.

“The battle against radial gender ideology is a battle for religious freedom, and it’s a battle we must fight,” Pence said, drawing a round of applause.  [snip]

Targeting trans rights isn’t just campaign fodder, either.

Last week, the GOP-controlled House of Representatives approved legislation on a party-line vote banning transgender athletes whose biological sex assigned at birth was male from competing on girls or women’s sports teams at federally supported schools and colleges. The bill has no chance of passage with a Democratic majority in the Senate and a Democrat in the White House, but it’s yet another sign of how the issue is resonating within the GOP.

Already this year, almost 500 anti-trans bills have been introduced in nearly every state in the country, including some that would require genital inspections. And while national Republicans have sought to target trans healthcare for minors, GOP-led states like Missouri are moving forward with measures that would severely curtail access to transgender healthcare writ large...

It's all part of the GQP's decades- long strategy to search out the most vulnerable, ostracized minority and afflict it for political gain.  If they can give it the veneer of religious "values," all the better.


Wednesday, April 19, 2023

The Inadequate Dominion Settlement




Yesterday's massive out-of-court financial damage settlement against Fox "News" for knowingly lying about Dominion Voting System machines rigging the vote for President Biden was partially satisfying, but after what the propaganda network did to American democracy it's inadequate. CNN's senior media reporter Oliver Darcy has this take:

"The case exposed Fox News as a dishonest organization like never before. It’s hard for any fair-minded observer to consider the channel as anything other than a propaganda profit machine void of the most basic ethics. The case shredded to pieces the little that remained of the talk channel’s credibility.

Some observers hoped this case would proceed to trial, bringing with it accountability and exposing the network even more. It unquestionably would have been an excruciating several weeks for Fox News. The channel’s highest-ranking executives and biggest stars, such as Tucker Carlson and Sean Hannity, would have been forced to confront how lies they never believed were promoted on the network’s air to its millions of loyal viewers.

Outside the embarrassment Fox News would have suffered, the settlement also spared the company and its executives of being bound by the laws of reality during trial. Normally, Fox News sails through controversy by distorting the criticism it faces and attacking “the media.” That time-tested playbook would not have worked in court, where the judge would have forced the network’s lawyers to present the jury a fact-based argument. In other words, the network would have been forced to enter the true No Spin Zone. And that’s always been a No Go Zone for the channel when confronting crises." (our emphasis)

So while it's satisfying that Fox paid a large sum, it's only 28% of their 2022 cable news profits. Given the additional humiliation they would have faced had this suit gone to trail, they wisely cut their losses, much to our disappointment. Also under the settlement, they apparently weren't required to broadcast an admission of their lies to their gullible MAGA audience, a major missed opportunity. 

Next up, the Smartmatic voting systems lawsuit is churning away, and at $2.7 billion in requested damages, it should take another shovel full out of Rupert Murdoch's bullshit mountain. But next time, make them all sit in front of a jury for a few weeks.

 

Tuesday, April 18, 2023

BREAKING: Fox Settles Defamation Suit With Dominion

 



The weasels avoided a jury trial after all:

Fox News agreed to settle a defamation lawsuit brought by Dominion Voting Systems on Tuesday for $787.5 million, according to an attorney for the voting technology company, representing a stunning conclusion to one of the most-watched media trials in decades. The judge dismissed jurors just hours after they had been selected. Dominion sued for $1.6 billion over allegations that Fox defamed the voting company by either knowingly or recklessly airing false claims tying voting machines to a conspiracy to undermine the 2020 presidential election. Some of Fox’s biggest stars and executives were expected to testify in the trial that was expected to test the limits of U.S. libel law.

Dominion's CEO had this reaction to the settlement:

After reaching a settlement against Fox News, Dominion CEO John Paulos told reporters outside a courthouse in Delaware that “Fox has admitted to telling lies about Dominion that caused enormous damage to my company, our employees and the customers that we serve.”

In a statement, Dominion said the settlement was “historic.” The statement also repeated the claim that “Fox has admitted to telling lies about Dominion that caused enormous damage to my Company, our employees, and our customers.”

But, there's still more accountability coming, according to Dominion lawyer Stephen Shackleford:

Dominion attorney Stephen Shackelford hinted at more litigation regarding election conspiracy theories, citing challenges Dominion employees still face over election misinformation.

“Money is accountability, and we got that today from Fox, but we’re not done yet. We’ve got some other people who have some accountability coming toward them,” he said. “And we’ll move right on to the next one.”

This could refer to individuals like Rudy Giuliani, Mein Pillow guy Mike Lindell, and others, who spread lies while on the air at Fox "News."

Keep in mind also that the $2.7 billion defamation suit brought by Smartmatic is proceeding:

Fox News’s legal troubles related to the 2020 presidential election are far from over, despite its settlement with Dominion Voting Systems announced Tuesday afternoon. In February, a New York appeals court ruled that a $2.7 billion defamation lawsuit against Fox News by another voting systems company — Smartmatic — was allowed to proceed.

After Fox News’s settlement with Dominion was announced Tuesday, Smartmatic attorney J. Erik Connolly released a blistering statement.

“Dominion’s litigation exposed some of the misconduct and damage caused by Fox’s disinformation campaign. Smartmatic will expose the rest,” Connolly said. “Smartmatic remains committed to clearing its name, recouping the significant damage done to the company, and holding Fox accountable for undermining democracy.”

Smartmatic filed its complaint in New York State Supreme Court in February 2021, alleging that lies broadcast on Fox News about the company “decimated” its business. In addition to Fox News, the complaint named Fox’s on-air hosts Maria Bartiromo, Lou Dobbs and Jeanine Pirro, as well as Donald Trump’s former lawyers Rudy Giuliani and Sidney Powell.

Finally, we heard a smarmy, self- serving statement from Fox, an organization that continues to provide lies to its audience as a matter of doing business (our emphasis):

In a statement, Fox said it was “pleased” to have settled the case. “We acknowledge the Court’s rulings finding certain claims about Dominion to be false,” it said, adding the settlement “reflects FOX’s continued commitment to the highest journalistic standards. We are hopeful that our decision to resolve this dispute with Dominion amicably, instead of the acrimony of a divisive trial, allows the country to move forward from these issues.”

The response from CNN's Jake Tapper to Fox's nopology and "highest journalistic standards" is the proper one:


 

 BONUS:  Jimmy Kimmel had his take on the settlement deal (starting around 3:00)--

“The liars who knowingly misled their oatmeal-brained viewers and seriously damaged our democracy don’t have to say anything about it at all ― no apologies, no testimony.  They can go right back to sodomizing the country while Dominion and their lawyers go shopping for yachts.”