Showing posts with label 2024 polls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2024 polls. Show all posts

Sunday, September 8, 2024

Silver Tongued Charlatan (UPDATED)

 



Want to bet Trump- friendly pollster Nate Silver has some skin in the 2024 election polling game?

Nate Silver, the celebrity statistician who gained notoriety for his FiveThirtyEight election models, is facing backlash over alleged skewing in his new model.

Silver left the ABC-owned company and launched his own Substack, the Silver Bulletin, last year. Since then, he’s become increasingly critical of the FiveThirtyEight projection and its behind-the-scenes assumptions and adjustments.  [snip]

...Silver has adopted the FiveThirtyEight system of weighting polls differently, ostensibly based on reliability. He's  facing criticism for allegedly favoring junk polls over respected pollsters.

“Patriot Polling is literally run by two right wing high school students that is ranked 240th on FiveThirtyEight,” former pollster Adam Carlson noted on X, asking why that poll was weighted more highly than a YouGov poll, which they called “an internationally respected pollster that is ranked 4th on FiveThirtyEight.” 

Some users believe that Silver’s methods of weighting polls are dubious, especially as his swing state calculated “polling averages” move in the opposite direction as recently released swing state polls. 

Silver's now being scrutinized for a potential conflict of interest after joining the crypto-based gambling company Polymarket as an advisor in July, and pushed his model while promoting election betting opportunities.

“Feels like it should be a bigger deal that Nate Silver is employed by Polymarket, a site that allows you to bet on political outcomes, and also runs a “prediction model” that has the ability to directly affect betting behavior,” journalist Brett Meiselas wrote on X.

Silver’s model  gives Trump a greater chance of winning than most forecasts, which has earned him fans in MAGA World. Those new boosters include former President Trump, who used Silver's model as evidence that he wasn’t losing as badly as polling averages suggested.

"Potential conflict of interest" is, to coin a phrase, "scamwashing."  What's also red- flagging "scam!" is his employer's crypto connection.  To the extent he's skewing polling projections to boost betting behavior, it's having the dangerous, more consequential effect of giving the Malignant Loser ammunition for claiming "I was ahead in all the polls! Stolen election!" when he loses in November, for which  he's already laying the groundwork --


 

Best advice:  ignore the polls and pollsters (especially Silver), and get to the polls and vote. 

UPDATE:  Turns out the company paying Silver is a Peter Thiel outfit.  Follow the money!


Sunday, August 25, 2024

The RFK, Jr., Effect? A Big Nothingburger

 



As many surmised, it's looking like the electoral impact of the decision by brain worm infested RFK, Jr., to drop out of the presidential race and endorse the highest bidder, i.e., the Malignant Loser, is most likely a wash:

... Both Trump and Kamala Harris have gained ground versus yesterday’s model run, the last one to include Kennedy. Harris’s polling average has improved from 48.0 percent yesterday to 48.8 percent today (+0.8), while Trump’s has increased from 43.7 to 44.8 (+1.1).

There are a couple of essential things to note here. First, yes, Trump has gained slightly more than Harris from the change, although it’s pretty minor, a net gain of 0.3 percentage points... And second, we’re seeing the beginnings of a convention bounce for Harris. Even with the Kennedy change, she’s now ahead by 4.0 points in the national polling average versus 2.3 points when the DNC started. Our best guess is that her lead will increase further, especially given that almost none of the polling was done after her strong acceptance speech on Thursday...

The electorate's impression of the bear- dumping, conspiracy- mongering, endlessly effed- up Kennedy was already a negative one going into this weekend, making his quid pro quo endorsement of the convicted felon macht nichts (using all our language skillz here).  If anything, getting his endorsement has crystallized the Malignant Loser's "coalition of the weird" impression, of which voters are ever more aware.

This is by no means to say Democrats should be complacent (see 2000 and 2016).  As the Harris-Walz campaign says, it's a race to election day and we've got to see ourselves as underdogs regardless of the polls -- because people vote, polls don't.  We need to win this.

(Cartoon:  David Rowe, Financial Review, Sydney, Australia)


Wednesday, May 15, 2024

Polls And The New York Times




From a discussion this morning on MSNBC, Joe Scarborough has had enough of those New York Times / Sienna polls that consistently show the Malignant Loser with a big lead in key states, polls that are outliers and are questioned by experts about the methodology:

"That keeps happening every month when this comes out and then about two weeks later after the residue of the New York Times/Siena poll leaves, people go, 'Oh, I think Joe Biden is on a winning streak. And then two weeks later it comes out again and it's garbage it's an outlier. And yes, the New York Times, when they have all of these experts questioning the methodology, when they are calling 20 percent of the people likely voters who had never voted before or didn't vote in the last two primaries or never voted before, when they are even quoting people who say they are switching their vote from Joe Biden who have never voted before? I'm sorry! The New York Times has to know what they are doing! "  (our emphasis)

The argument is that the New York F-ing Times is using garbage numbers to create stories that drive the news cycle and interest in the paper's coverage. There's also the obvious factor that the paper's executives are angry with President Biden for not giving them an exclusive interview. Giving the cynics at the New York F-ing Times an opportunity to cut you down is not what the Biden campaign needs. Also, perhaps the President remembers what the paper did to Hillary Clinton's campaign in the last few weeks with their damaging and over-hyped "Hillary's e-mails" coverage which aided the Malignant Loser's campaign.

BONUS:  In the real world of actual voting- at- the- polls, the Malignant Loser continues to lose Republican voters to long- ago dropout Nikki Haley -- losing 20% in Maryland and 18% in deep- red Nebraska.  Sad! (but more believable than the New York F-ing Times)!

BONUS II:  More analysis of the polling flaws and what it chooses to emphasize.

(image: Shutterstock)