Showing posts with label Judge Tanya Chutkan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Judge Tanya Chutkan. Show all posts

Thursday, September 5, 2024

Chutkan: Trump Insurrection Trial Going Forward

 



Fortunately, we have a jurist in U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan who's not overwhelmed by the moment or intimidated by the convicted felon Malignant Loser's team of crime family lawyers.  The January 6 insurrection trial inches forward:

Judge Tanya Chutkan, overseeing a case against former President Donald Trump for his role on Jan. 6, said that Judge Aileen Cannon’s ruling calling special counsel Jack Smith’s appointment illegitimate was not “particularly persuasive,” and signaled the case may move forward despite the election schedule.

Chutkan on Thursday re-arraigned Trump on a new superseding indictment from Smith’s office, made to exclude potentially official acts he made as president involving the attacks following the Supreme Court’s wide presidential immunity decision.

Responding to Trump attorney John Lauro’s suggestion that allowing prosecutors to file a brief containing evidence would put harmful details into the public record "at this very sensitive time,” Chutkan said the law was not concerned with political sensitivities.

“The electoral process and the timing of the election and what needs to happen before  . . . is not relevant here. This court is not concerned with the electoral schedule,” Chutkan said, per Politico reporter Kyle Cheney.

Chutkan went on to ask Trump’s attorneys why they were filing a motion to challenge the legitimacy of Smith’s appointment, citing Clarence Thomas’ dissent in Trump v. United States and Judge Cannon’s ruling, tossing out a case involving Trump’s illegal handling of classified documents. The judge noted that they missed an October deadline to file and that D.C. Circuit precedent held Smith’s appointment was valid.

“You have an opinion by a district judge in another circuit which frankly this court doesn't find persuasive,” Chutkan reportedly said, per Lawfare’s Roger Parloff.

Chutkan, who also disagreed with Lauro’s characterization that the Supreme Court’s ruling already settled whether conversations between Trump and Pence were official acts, according to MSNBC correspondent Katie Phang, didn’t dismiss the conversation outright, noting that if Trump’s team could persuade the court that the D.C. Circuit precedent didn’t hold, she’d reconsider.

At one point in the hearing, Lauro cracked a joke that “life was almost meaningless” while the case was on hold for months. To which Chutkan fired back, "Enjoy it while it lasts." (our emphasis)

Clearly, she intends to proceed with all due haste with the re-focused superseding indictment.  We look forward to the Special Counsel's evidentiary brief.  

You can bet the ketchup is flying fast and furious at Mar-a-Lardo.

(Composite image:  Agence France- Presse/Getty Images)

Thursday, August 15, 2024

The Road Map For Trump's January 6 Insurrection Trial And Conviction



As he awaits sentencing for 34 felony fraud counts in New York State, the prospects of the Malignant Loser going to trial for his part in the January 6 coup and insurrection haven't been seriously diminished by the Republican Supreme Court's immunity decision in Trump v. United States, according to one expert.

This is a lengthy excerpt from an op/ed by Richard Lazarus, Charles Stebbins Fairchild Professor of Law at Harvard Law School, in today's Washington Post:

... The chief justice’s opinion leaves little doubt that [Judge Tanya] Chutkan can now validly conclude that Trump is not entitled to any immunity from felony prosecution (even though he was president at the time) for the calls and meetings he held with state and local election officials to persuade them to block the election results. The court ruled that any immunity Trump enjoys, whether absolute or presumptive in nature, is limited to “official acts.” There is no immunity for actions that are “unofficial” in nature. The court accordingly invited Chutkan to analyze Trump’s “interactions with a wide variety of state officials and private persons” to determine whether those interactions were official or unofficial in nature. But Roberts’s opinion did not hesitate to make clear that Chutkan could legitimately conclude that all these contacts were unofficial in nature. The court carefully pointed out that “this alleged conduct cannot be neatly categorized as falling within a particular Presidential function.”

The court similarly left little doubt that Chutkan was free to conclude that the speeches Trump made to the general public, including the rally on Jan. 6, which prosecutors alleged were designed to incite the mob that attacked the Capitol, were unofficial in nature and therefore not entitled to any immunity. The chief justice expressly acknowledged that there are “contexts in which the President … speaks in an unofficial capacity.” And to drive the point home, he offers an example: “as a candidate for office.” The reference is hardly subtle. The court is peremptorily endorsing a finding that, based on Chutkan’s “objective analysis” of “content, form, and context,” Trump’s speeches were those of a “candidate for office” and not entitled to immunity from prosecution.  [snip]

Finally, it is quite clear that the special counsel can secure a conviction without relying on any of the evidence that the Supreme Court ruled must be out of bounds on immunity grounds even for a prosecution of unofficial acts that are not subject to immunity. That includes evidence of Trump’s “discussions with Justice Department officials” about securing an official opinion suggesting fraud in the 2020 election. While such evidence would certainly have weighed in favor of a jury’s finding the former president guilty, the special counsel has more than enough incriminating evidence without it, beginning with the stunning recordings of Trump’s conversations with officials in states such as Georgia...

While it will not go to trial before the election, the evidence of the Malignant Loser's guilt can be laid out in time for the public to be reminded of his disqualifying, authoritarian conduct once again.  We may yet see him get his comeuppance like so many of his frothing followers have, especially if Vice President Harris prevails.  He may want to book that flight to Venezuela (or more likely Moscow) soon.

(Illustration:  Salon/Getty Images)


Saturday, December 2, 2023

Quotes Of The Day -- No Immunity For You!

 

Two significant rulings yesterday on the Malignant Loser's attempts to claim presidential immunity for his actions leading up to the January 6 insurrection:


"...President Trump moved in the district court to dismiss the claims against him, including on grounds of a President’s official-act immunity from damages liability. The district court largely rejected his claim of immunity, and President Trump now appeals. The sole issue before us is whether President Trump has demonstrated an entitlement to official-act immunity for his actions leading up to and on January 6 as alleged in the complaints.

"We answer no, at least at this stage of the proceedings. When a first-term President opts to seek a second term, his campaign to win re-election is not an official presidential act.The Office of the Presidency as an institution is agnostic about who will occupy it next. And campaigning to gain that office is not an official act of the office. So, when a sitting President running for a second term attends a private fundraiser for his re-election effort, hires (or fires) his campaign staff, cuts a political ad supporting his candidacy, or speaks at a campaign rally funded and organized by his re-election campaign committee, he is not carrying out the official duties of the presidency. He is acting as office-seeker, not office-holder—no less than are the persons running against him when they take precisely the same actions in their competing campaigns to obtain precisely the same office..." -- page 4 of D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals Chief Judge Sri Srinivasan's ruling yesterday on whether the Malignant Loser had immunity from civil suits filed by injured police officers and Members of Congress for his insurrectionist remarks leading up to the January 6 Capitol sacking.  The two other judges on the three- judge panel concurred in the ruling but had additional comments.

____________________


"...Defendant contends that the Constitution grants him “absolute immunity from criminal prosecution for actions performed within the ‘outer perimeter’ of his official responsibility”while he served as President of the United States, so long as he was not both impeached and convicted for those actions. Immunity Motion at 8, 11–13 (formatting modified). The  Constitution’s text, structure, and history do not support that contention. No court—or any other branch of government—has ever accepted it. And this court will not so hold. Whatever immunities a sitting President may enjoy, the United States has only one Chief Executive at a time, and that position does not confer a lifelong “get-out-of-jail-free” pass. Former Presidents enjoy no special conditions on their federal criminal liability. Defendant may be subject to federal investigation, indictment, prosecution, conviction, and punishment for any criminal acts undertaken while in office..."
-- page 6 of U.S. District Court Judge Tanya Chutkan's ruling yesterday denying the Malignant Loser's claim of immunity in the January 6 insurrection prosecution.

The rulings, by two separate courts, bolster the government's position that the Malignant Loser is not above the law, should further appeals be made.


Monday, August 28, 2023

Hearing On Jan. 6 Trial Date Today (UPDATED)



Today Federal District Court Judge Tanya Chutkan will be hearing arguments from Special Counsel Jack Smith and the lawyers for the Malignant Loser on the trial date for felony charges related to his January 6 attempted coup and events leading up to that day. Smith is seeking a start date of January 2, 2024, while the Malignant Loser's lawyers are risibly asking for a start date of April 2026, roughly two and a half years after his August 1 indictment and a clear attempt to stall the trial and justice. From the New York Times:

"In most legal proceedings, the selection of a trial date is a largely mundane matter, depending on the number of defendants, the amount of evidence, and the schedules of the judge, prosecutors and defense lawyers.

But the timetables for Mr. Trump’s four trials have taken on outsize importance. That is not only because there are so many of them, each one needing a slot, but also because they are unfolding against Mr. Trump’s crowded calendar as the candidate leading the field for the Republican Party’s 2024 presidential nomination.

As a further complication, Mr. Trump has made no secret in private conversations with his aides of his desire to solve his jumble of legal problems by winning the election. If either of the two federal trials he is confronting is delayed until after the race and Mr. Trump prevails, he could seek to pardon himself after taking office or have his attorney general simply dismiss the matters altogether.

At Monday’s hearing in Washington on the federal election charges, Judge Chutkan has said she also intends to discuss a schedule for handling the small amount of classified material that may emerge as evidence in the case. If she ultimately agrees to the government’s request to start the trial in January, it would be the first of Mr. Trump’s four cases to be tested in a courtroom." (our emphasis)

Hopefully, Judge Chutkan, who has warned the Malignant Loser's lawyers to keep their lawless client from intimidating witnesses and potential jurors, will also address his recent incendiary comments on social media promising revenge against his opponents. She has warned that if he persists, his trial date would be scheduled sooner, a strategy that the judges in his other three criminal cases should, but probably won't, follow.

UPDATE:  The judge set the trial date for March 4, 2024.


Wednesday, November 10, 2021

QOTD -- Not A King, Not Even A President

 

"Presidents are not kings, and Plaintiff is not President." -- U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan in her ruling permitting the January 6 select committee to receive documents related to the insurrection that the Malignant Loser ("Plaintiff") has tried to block.  The Malignant Loser has filed a notice of appeal to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit.

You can read the judge's full opinion here (pdf).