Showing posts with label Rep. Paul Ryan's FY 2015 budget. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rep. Paul Ryan's FY 2015 budget. Show all posts
Sunday, April 6, 2014
Saturday, April 5, 2014
Flashback
In the 1936 election, one year after President Roosevelt signed the law creating Social Security, his Republican opponent Alf Landon called it a "cruel hoax" and promised to repeal it.
Landon won just two states—and, four years later, Republican nominee Wendell Willkie ran on expanding Social Security. Although congressional Republicans continued guerrilla warfare against the program into the 1950s, the prospect of full-scale repeal sank with Landon.
In 1964, Republican presidential nominee Barry Goldwater staunchly opposed the creation of Medicare, the health program for the elderly proposed by President Johnson. But after Johnson routed Goldwater and then pushed Medicare through Congress in 1965, opposition collapsed. By 1968, Republican presidential nominee Richard Nixon accepted it as settled law.Meanwhile, today's reactionary Republicans want to do what?
[Rep. Paul "Lyin'"] Ryan's defiant budget—coming immediately after the rush that produced more than 7 million enrollments on the health care exchanges, plus at least another 4 million sign-ups under Medicaid—captured how much momentum the repeal cause retains in the GOP. How far apart are the two sides? Ryan's plan would not only undo the insurance expansions under Obamacare but also impose further sharp cuts on Medicaid, eventually eliminating existing coverage for an additional 15 million to 20 million people. (our emphasis)Brownstein's piece is titled "The Health Care Reform War Without End." For nearly 100 years, the Republican Party has been philosophically opposed to government involvement in ameliorating the lives of the most vulnerable Americans, specifically its providing protections (a "safety net") for those Americans. That long-held view has been further radicalized in the past 30-or-so years by the ascendance of what was once a fringe part of the conservative movement, but is now at its cold, beating heart: far-right libertarianism =cough= Paul Ryan = cough= Rand Paul =cough=. From 1935 to today, every effort to protect the vulnerable, the elderly, the poor, has been met with implacable hostility from reactionary Republicans. It's always helpful to be reminded that every victory is just a battle won in a longer war -- a "War Without End."
BONUS: Nice companion piece by Michael Tomasky on what Republicans are really all about.
Thursday, April 3, 2014
More On Rep. Paul Ryan's "Stinkburger" Budget
The LA Times' Michael Hiltzik discusses how the budget put forth by media darling (and a stupid man's idea of what a smart man sounds like) Rep. Paul "Lyin'" Ryan (Ayn Rand-WI) is designed to
As I've written before, when you hear people like Paul Ryan talk as though the country can't afford to pay back the money by redeeming the bonds in the trust fund, what you're hearing is the sound of the wealthy preparing to stiff the working class. If the income tax has to be raised to turn those T-bonds into cash for payment of benefits over the next couple of decades, that's how the rich will be made to repay the people who lent them the money. Some people love to claim that the government has "stolen" the trust fund. The correct reply to that is: "Not yet."
But if Ryan has his way, yes, the money will be stolen. It's up to you and me to make sure that doesn't happen.
So, to put all these pieces together, there's no "dubious government accounting" involved here--the dubious accounting is all Ryan's. The trust fund is indeed a real savings account, involving deposits and interest. Yes, the government borrowed the money, and it has paid interest on it every year (duly recorded and published, down to the last dollar, in the annual reports of the Social Security trustees).
And yes, "the ability to redeem these securities is completely dependent on the Treasury’s ability to raise money through taxes or borrowing." What Ryan doesn't say is that the Treasury's ability to raise taxes and borrowing is effectively unlimited.
The most important factor is the one that people like Ryan want you to forget: The money in the Social Security trust fund came directly or indirectly from the payroll taxes paid by millions of American workers--100% of it. It was paid by workers in the trust that the government would pay it back. Paul Ryan is hinting, pretty strongly, that he doesn't want to pay it back.As Hiltzik points out (and please take time to read his entire article), this part of Ryan's stinkburger budget repeats language in his FY 2012 budget proposal. It's not "reform." It's another foray in the far-right's war on the middle class, another stratagem in the fight to increase income inequality in this country. As Hiltzik says, we have to make sure that doesn't happen.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

