Looking no further than the op/ ed pages of the Washington Post, there's plenty of commentary about the conduct of the Republican Supreme Court (RSCOTUS) during oral arguments in the anti- abortion case of Dobbs v Jackson Women's Health Organization. Here are a few snippets.
The Editorial Board
The Supreme Court heard arguments Wednesday in an abortion case
that could mark a perilous turning point for American society. Judging
by the justices’ tone, the question is not whether they will eviscerate
the 1973 Roe v. Wade decision and the subsequent Planned Parenthood v. Casey ruling
in 1992 but how drastically they will curtail these core precedents.
The justices should have no illusions: A partial or total reversal of Roe
would devastate not only the Americans who rely on the abortion rights
that have been theirs for nearly 50 years, but also the court itself,
undermining its legitimacy. [snip]
The other shift since Roe has been the makeup of the court,
reshaped after the addition of several conservative justices due to a
mixture of underhanded politics and pure happenstance. The court’s
authority derives not from its ability to enforce its declarations — it
lacks any such power — but from the fact that Americans respect its
decisions. Those decisions must reflect something greater than mere whim
or raw political power in the Senate. The court should overturn
precedent only in exceptional circumstances. The justices must exercise
particular care in the case of Roe, because the court previously reviewed and reaffirmed it in Casey, reinforcing its status as the law of the land.
In such a circumstance, the court should reverse only decisions that
have proved, with the wisdom of hindsight, to be wildly bad. That is not
the case with Roe or Casey.
Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh on Wednesday cited landmark cases such as Brown v. Board of Education,
which overturned previous court holdings, to argue that the court
sometimes makes its most important decisions when it breaks with past
rulings. The justices should take no comfort in this strained
comparison. If the court substantially reverses or strikes Roe,
Americans will not remember it as a moment of overdue progress but as an
undue contraction of Americans’ constitutional rights that does deep
and immediate harm to millions. That would indeed be a bleak day for the
court.
Dana Milbank
The six Republican-appointed justices on the Supreme Court left no doubt
in oral argument Wednesday that they would end the constitutional right
to abortion that American women have had for nearly half a century. The
court will either overturn Roe v. Wade outright or cripple the landmark ruling
by eliminating the “fetal viability” standard at its core. Both would
return us to a time before most people living ever knew, when state
legislatures controlled women’s reproductive decisions.
Public
opinion hasn’t changed. The science hasn’t fundamentally changed. No
new legal theory has been promulgated. The only difference is the court
now has a majority hellbent on settling scores in the culture wars.
“Will this institution survive the stench that this creates in the
public perception that the Constitution and its reading are just
political acts?” Justice Sonia Sotomayor asked her colleagues. “I don’t see how it is possible.”
There’s
good reason, Justice Elena Kagan said, why the Supreme Court has given
great weight to precedent — and particularly to “super precedent” such
as the 1973 Roe decision, affirmed by the 1992 Planned Parenthood v. Casey decision.
It’s “to prevent people from thinking that this court is a political
institution that will go back and forth depending on what part of the
public yells the loudest.”
E.J. Dionne, Jr
On Tuesday, four high school students — ages 14, 16 and 17 — were fatally shot in Oxford, Mich., by a 15-year-old classmate firing a 9mm pistol with 15-round magazines.
Less than 24 hours later, a Supreme Court majority that seems on the verge of weakening the nation’s gun laws heard arguments in a case that could lead to tougher restrictions on abortion. [snip]
Here’s what we’re facing: conservative jurists ready to expand states’
rights when it comes to limiting or banning abortion but equally
prepared to block states from enacting gun laws aimed at protecting the
right of their people to live beyond their teenage years.
There will be hell to pay when the decision comes down next year. Remember what party put these troglodytes on the Court and act accordingly.