Showing posts with label Jill Lawrence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jill Lawrence. Show all posts

Wednesday, May 22, 2024

Rebalancing The Smug, Immodest, Corrupt Supreme Court

 



We have two worthwhile reads on the illegitimate Republican Supreme Court this morning. We're only posting brief extracts, so please go to the links for the full reads.

First, conservative Jill Lawrence's views on the Court have been evolving:

... Until recently I was skeptical about both term limits and Court expansion. I didn’t sense the political will for either one, and I wasn’t sure either was warranted. But since the immunity hearing, and after many rulings detached from precedent, practicality, or public opinion, I’ve had zero doubt about the need for term limits and I’m even warming up to the prospect of a thirteen-justice Court.

The point of all of this is not to pack the Court and send it screeching left, but to rebalance and stabilize an institution that has grown smug, immodest, inured to ethics abuses, and cavalier to constitutional and national concerns and freedoms—starting with whether a president who tried to stay in power despite losing an election should be tried for that before voters pass judgment on his third presidential campaign.

Meanwhile, Dan Pfeiffer writes about why the Court can be a big election issue for Democrats:

...This is the court that overturned Roe v. Wade and is helping ensure Trump avoids accountability for his crimes. They are corrupt and out of touch with mainstream American values.  [snip]

Running against a corrupt court is pushing on an open door. American faith in the Supreme Court is at an all-time low.  

 

[snip]

Making voters — especially the less politically engaged — care about the Supreme Court is difficult. To succeed, we have to explain why it matters to their lives; how the rulings of a MAGA court will restrict their freedoms and be a boon to powerful interests. The fundamental question of this election is whether Democrats can hold together the anti-MAGA majority that won elections in 2017, 2018, 2019, 2020, 2022, and 2023. The best way to do that is to make this election about something bigger than a contest between two men. The Supreme Court is a perfect issue to go big.

Both Lawrence and Pfeiffer are coming at the problem from somewhat opposite ends of the political spectrum, but both agree something fairly drastic needs to be done to undo the damage wrought by packing the Court with Republican/ Federalist Society extremists, starting with the modest step of establishing ethics rules.  

Expanding the Court or establishing term limits may be aspirational to the point of fantasy, at least during this era of extremist right- wing revanchism. But, in 2024, campaigning on the real world consequences of an out- of- touch extremist Court in the lives of the average American -- e.g., losing reproductive freedom, caving to special interests like the gun lobby and industrial polluters -- can be the first step toward building a coalition for change and reform.  The lesson to be learned from the right's decades- long project to reshape the Court is that this process is a marathon, not a sprint.

(Cartoon:  Joe Heller, hellertoon.com)


Tuesday, January 9, 2018

Today's Reading


Let's start off with what Jill Lawrence said:
There’s no need for Democrats to overthink 2018. It’s very simple: At every decision point, they should ask themselves WWRD — What Would Republicans Do? — and then do it. 
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell is sounding like a born-again believer in compromise, but only out of necessity. His challenges include a tiny 51-49 majority and ominous signs for the upcoming midterm elections. No wonder he said in welcoming two new Democratic senators last week, “I look forward to working with them in the months ahead to make bipartisan progress and to find common ground on behalf of the American people.” 
Where was that man during the Obama administration? [snip] 
There’s no reason to reward McConnell for his two-term blockade of President Obama, especially when it could help him limit damage to congressional Republicans running this fall. So how would this legislative hardball look  in practice? 
Lawrence provides some examples of where Democrats should stand firm and hold out for big wins for their values.  The Republican Party, now more than ever, should not be treated as a serious partner in governance.  That ship sailed and is never returning to port. It's time for the Democratic Party to play the hardball Lawrence recommends and not "overthink" 2018.

Roy Edroso at The Village Voice notes the real interest of Michael Wolff's "Fire and Fury":
[T]he book itself, however true and/or entertaining it may be, is politically unimportant, because 1) we already knew Trump was an asshole, and 2) for the 40 percent of Americans who approve of him, being an asshole is clearly a large part of his appeal. [snip]

No, the main interest of the book is as a stimulus for Republicans and rightbloggers to take their sycophancy to the next level and defend Trump from accusations that he acts pretty much like everyone already knows he acts.
Edroso follows with some examples of the Flying Monkey brigades jumping to the defense of their hero, the Very Stable Genius.

On the religious huckster front, there's the latest shakedown/ grift from one of Trump's "spiritual" advisers, Paula White:
Paula White, a prosperity gospel preacher with close ties to President Donald Trump, is calling on followers to send her donations of up to one month’s salary. Those who don’t pay up could face “consequences” from God as he demands the dough as a “first fruits” offering. 
“The reason is God lays claim to all firsts,” White wrote on her website. “So when you keep for yourself something that belongs to God you are desecrating what is to be consecrated to God.” [snip]
While White said these firsts “belong to God and God alone,” she wants them sent to her in the form of offerings to her ministries.  
Hahaha. Well of course she does. It must be like that "pass- through" provision in the Republican wealthfare tax act.

Last but not least, Infidel has his encyclopedic link round- up with something for everyone. Always worth a visit.